I wore DiorShow and DiorShow Blackout for YEARS. Then they changed the formula....now it seems to never dry and smears on my eyelids throughout the day, so I’m on the hunt for a new fav! I decided to try out 5 mascaras (all in Black or Blackest Black) that I keep seeing everywhere. As a (self proclaimed) mascara expert aficionado, I put them to the test! I was looking more for volume, but a bit of extra length was a plus too. First up, this one seemed to be a lot of people’s holy grail: Maybelline Lash Sensational Sky High ($8.99 Target) Pros for me - Looks natural, lengthens nicely, buildable for more length/volume Cons for me- Flimsy wand (I like a wand that doesn’t bend, but some people don’t!) Overall - Pretty dang good! 4.5/5 L’Oréal Voluminous Lash Paradise ($8.99 Target) Pros for me - Sturdy, big wand, only needed one coat, grips lashes well Cons for me - VERY thick, can clump easily Overall- Eh, it’s ok. A little spidery for me! 3.5/5 L’Oréal Telescopic ($8.69 Targe